Platos argument rests on several crucial assumptions concerning the effect of poetry on an audience. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of the republic and what it means. At some point, aristotles original work was divided in two, each book written on a separate. In aristotles poetics on the other hand, he highlights the importance of imitation not just in art, but also in everyday life and why imitation within tragedy is necessary for human development. Plato and aristotle argue that artist demiurge and poet imitate nature, thus, a work of art is a relection of nature. Aristotle s poetics is here presented in a unique edition together with related extracts from plato and more modern responses to aristotle from sir philip sidney, shelley, and dorothy l. A founding text of european aesthetics and literary criticism, it has shaped much of our modern understanding of the creation and impact of imaginative writing, including poetry, drama, and fiction. He focuses his critique entirely on book v of the republic, which lays out the need for common property and for the communism of women and children. Poetry is a core part of human nature, and the impulse to write poetry comes from an innate curiosity, a tendency to imitate the things around us. Contents analysis of contents aristotles poetics i ii iii iv v vi vii viii ix x xi xii xiii xiv xv xvi xvii imitation the common principle of the arts of poetry.
Translated by ingram bywater, with a preface by gilbert murray. In the poetics aristotle claims that imitators imitate men who are doing something poetics, i, p70, that tragedy is an imitation not of men but of actions and life poetics, vi, p77. Of the greek authors who at the re naissance brought a new life into the world plato has had the greatest in. Jan 09, 20 that imitation has harmful effects is a complex matter. At some point, aristotle s original work was divided in two, each book written on a separate roll of papyrus. Poetics by aristotle, part of the internet classics archive. Dec 14, 2012 poetics by aristotle 384322 bc translated by ingram bywater 18401914 aristotle s poetics from the 4th century b. He defines poetry as a medium of imitation that seeks to represent or duplicate life through character, emotion, or action. In the poetics, aristotle, platos student, attempts to refute his teacher by exploring what unites all. Top american libraries canadian libraries universal library community texts project gutenberg biodiversity heritage library childrens library. Google aristotle s poetics whole text and the republic by plato pdf ii.
The differences between aristotle s and platos ideas are brought into clear relief in this book. The poetics stands in opposition to the theory of art propounded by aristotle s teacher, plato. And for all these sayings they cite the poets as witnesses, with regard to the. Aristotle s poetics seeks to address the different kinds of poetry, the structure of a good poem, and the division of a poem into its component parts. This volume contains a close translation of these two books, together with a philosophical commentary. In book ii the critique of poetry focused on mimesis understood as. Then the book merely contained aristotle and horace on poetry and longinus on the sublime. Socrates believes he has adequately responded to thrasymachus and is through with the discussion of justice, but the others are not satisfied with the conclusion they have reached. Part i i propose to treat of poetry in itself and of its various kinds, notin. The objects of imitation are the actions of men, and the poets.
In the tenth book of the republic, when plato has completed his final burning denunciation of poetry, the false siren, the imitator of things which themselves are shadows, the ally of all that is low and weak in the soul against that which is high and strong, who makes us feed the things we ought to starve and serve the. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of politics and what it means. This system combines the title, a book and chapter number, and an extra number to specify the part of the text cited. For plato, there are three key objections to imitation mimesis which are demonstrated in books ii and iii, and then again in book x of the republic. Home \ video \ poetics by aristotle audio book more. Get an answer for how does aristotles p oetics answer platos ideas regarding art and its lack of utility in society. Aristotle certainly knew the passage, and it looks as if his treatise on poetry was an answer to platos challenge. Poetics dover thrift editions 9780486295770 by aristotle and a great selection of similar new, used and collectible books available now at great prices. Aristotles politics book iii summary and analysis gradesaver.
Aristotle distinguished between actuality and potentiality metaphysics, xi. Aristotle s poetics whole text and platos republic only sections on mimesis in books ii, iii, and v of the republic. After a thorough discussion of the value of poetry, plato banishes it from his republic. Arguments of plato in the republic and aristotle in poetics. Long forgotten by commentators, it nevertheless had a great influence, since aristotles poetics has given birth to three concepts crucial for psychology, social sciences, and philosophy of art. The value and need for mimesis has been argued by a number of scholars including sigmund freud, philip sydney and adam smith, but this essay will focus on the arguments outlined by plato in the republic and aristotle in poetics, attempting to demonstrate the different features of imitation mimesis and what it involves for them both.
In his republic, plato argues that poetry is a representation of mere appearances and is thus misleading and morally suspect critical, 1. Art as imitation in plato and aristotle literary fruit. The poetics is in part aristotle s response to his teacher, plato, who argues in the republic that poetry is representation of mere appearances and is thus misleading and morally suspect. But he does not actually address any of those ideas. It is evident that self generating things have an intrinsic principle of motion and rest in them primarily and essentially, and not incidentally. In these first two books aristotle shows his complete mastery of political theory and practice, and raises many crucial issues still with us today.
The book is divided into short, fragmented sections that deals with every aspect of drama, poetry and epic. What is the most significant in difference between the. The second half of the book examines the nicomachean ethics. Fragments of a different version of platos republic were discovered in 1945, part of the nag hammadi library, written ca.
Aristotle s approach to the phenomenon of poetry is quite different from platos. Close section end matter from sir philip sidney, an apology for poetry. Platos republic book 10 poetry as corrupter of the soul. Sayers, aristotle on detective fiction a note on metre explanatory notes glossary of key terms index. This paper provides an overview and commentary of aristotle s theory of poetry, of drama, and of narrative structure, as presented the poetics. In book ii, aristotle tries to identify the means by which we explain change causes. Aristotles poetics can be read as a response to platos attack on art.
Book excerpt e of being an old word which is accepted and reinterpreted by aristotle rather than a word freely chosen by him to denote the exact phenomenon he wishes. For oxford worlds classics he has translated aristotle s eudemian ethics. Aristotles politics book ii summary and analysis gradesaver. Theres no introduction to the book, just a note about when it was written circa 330bc and about aristotle himself, taking up less than a page.
Res publica is a socratic dialogue, authored by plato around 375 bc, concerning justice. Start with the early dialogues and progress to the later ones. A quick guide to citing plato and aristotle proofeds. Ii since the objects of imitation are men in action, and these men must be either of a higher or a lower type for moral character mainly answers to these divisions, goodness and badness being the distinguishing marks of moral differences, it follows that we must represent men either as better than in real life, or as worse, or as they are. Book ii, chapter 1 nature is an intrinsic principle, art is extrinsic. A chronology of aristotle outline of the poetics from plato, republic, books 2, 3, and 10 aristotle, poetics from sir philip sidney, an apology for poetryfrom p. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Plato and the politics of aristotles poetics jstor. Butcher, aristotles theory of poetry and the fine arts new york. Additionally, aristotle s definition of citizens will also play an important role in his discussion of the best regime in book vii.
The internet classics archive poetics by aristotle. The second section offers an account of aristotle s idea of happiness as the end of action. The longer is the ideal and aims at maximum precision, requiring knowledge of the forms and a definition of the good. Arguments of plato in the republic and aristotle in poetics essay. It argues that, even though aristotle rejects a universal form of the good, he implicitly recognizes the existence of longer and shorter routes, analogous to those distinguished in the republic. Glaucon, one of socratess young companions, explains what they would like him to do. Jan 29, 2019 the selection of these thinkers has been motivated essentially by the fact that they complement each other in their judgment on poetry. From the poetics by aristotle devoted to literary criticism, only the first part mainly dedicated to the tragedy was received. They do not produce a true likeness of their topics. A continuation of book i, it extends the argument of justice vs injustice. The selections from plato illustrate the poetic philosophers surprising exclusion of poets from his ideal republic. This book compares the republic and nicomachean ethics from a methodological perspective.
Plato wrote about mimesis in both ion and the republic books ii, iii, and x. Aristotle s poetics is an early, and now classic, philosophical exploration of poetry along these sorts of lines. There are nearer approaches to modern metaphysics in the philebus and in the sophist. What books should i read to understand plato and aristotle. Greek was very much a live language, and a language still unconscious of grammar, not, like ours, dominated by definitions and trained upon dictionaries. Please click on the literary analysis category you wish to be displayed. Platos attitude to poetry and the fine arts, and the origins of aesthetics.
Several oxyrhynchus papyri fragments were found to contain parts of the republic, and from other works such as phaedo, or the dialogue gorgias, written around 200300 ce. Aristotle s work on aesthetics consists of the poetics, politics bk viii and rhetoric. The internet classics archive nicomachean ethics by. Top ten quotes namely 1 the habit of imitating is congenital to human beings from childhoodand so is 2 the pleasure that all men take in works of imitation. In book ii he launches a sharp attack on platos two utopias, the republic and the laws, and also criticizes three historical states reputed to be well governed. This paper discusses the concept of imitation in plato and aristotle.
His most recent book is a new history of western philosophy 2010. Unlike the dialogues of plato, none of aristotle s surviving works are noted for their literary craftsmanship, and, with the exception of the constitution of athens, were never intended for publication in their present form. This anthology brings together core classical texts for understanding literature. The rhetoric was developed by aristotle during two periods when he was in athens, the first between 367 to 347 bce when he was seconded to plato in. The republic of plato is the longest of his works with the exception of the laws, and is certainly the greatest of them. The first half argues that the republic distinguishes between two levels of argument in the defence of justice, the longer and shorter routes. Both plato and aristotle saw in mimesis the representation of nature, including human nature, as reflected in the dramas of the period. Many people prefer to read offline or to print out text and read from the real printed page. In book ii he claims that a young man must not be allowed to hear that he does nothing strange when he commits the most shocking offenses republic, ii, p25. Aristotle supposedly wrote a second book on comedy, which is now lost.
As the shortest book ive got on my literature student bookshelf, this dover thrift edition poetics is the cheapest, and most flimsy, but completely worthwhile book. In his response, poetics, aristotle draws on the works of the great greek playwrights to defend the value of the art. Here, walter watson offers a new interpretation of the lost second book of aristotles poetics. This system is based on an edition of aristotle s writing used by august immanuel bekker. Long forgotten by commentators, it nevertheless had a great influence, since aristotle s poetics has given birth to three concepts crucial for psychology, social sciences, and philosophy of art. The paper, which compares plato and aristotle s different approaches towards artistic activity, is divided into three parts. In book ii the critique of poetry focused on mimesis understood as representation.
He did not write a treatise on the subjectindeed, he wrote no treatises, and confined his thought to dramatic dialogues that are themselves shaped. Because aristotle thinks that not all people have the capacity to rule, in the best regime only an elite few will actually be citizens. On the second book of aristotles poetics and the source of. In the politics, also, aristotle, speaking of the term k0oapats promises to discuss it. Malcolm heaths introduction fills almost half the book but he truly captures the essence of poetics. Classic readings and canadian cases in the philosophy of law pdf download. Earlier in the dialogue, socrates suggested that certain kinds of music and poetry should not be permitted in the curriculum of study for the future rulers of the state because some art did not seem to be morally uplifting, hence perhaps bad for children. Oct 27, 2012 here, we go through a brief summary, and my argument on platos the republic, book ii. In book i he argues vigorously for a political theory based on nature. Plato on rhetoric and poetry stanford encyclopedia of.
In aristotle s poetics on the other hand, he highlights the importance of imitation not just in art, but also in everyday life and why imitation within tragedy is necessary for human development. Homer wrote two great epics, the iliad and the odyssey, which deal with the fall of troy and. Arguments of plato in the republic and aristotle in. One of the first things aristotle tries to do in t he poetics is to define the characteristics which are common to painting, drama, poetry, music, etc that is, to define art. The internet classics archive nicomachean ethics by aristotle. He can be extremely difficult to understand, and the theory is that his writings were actually. Aristotle writes also that he will address catharsis and an analysis of what is funny. It has been a standard book for literary criticism since centuries. Sir anthony kenny is a distinguished philosopher whose books include the aristotelian ethics 1978, aristotle s theory of the will 1979, and aristotle on the perfect life 1992. The quest for a poetics of goodness in plato and aristotle. Aristotle s poetics is the most influential book on poetry ever written. English i preap and onlevel summer reading list and. Only the first part that which focuses on tragedy and epic as a quasidramatic art, given its definition in ch 23.
Plato on rhetoric and poetry stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. This core concept video focuses on platos republic book 10, specifically on his discussion of. Aristotle harshly attacks the republic at its weakest and most controversial points. Poetics by aristotle full text free book file size. Aristotle s politics is a key document in western political thought.
Platos extensive discussions of poetry frustrate these expectations. Back and next buttons can guide you through all the sections or you can choose to jump from section to section using the links below or. Against these judgments, we believe that aristotle can be defended if his dialectical strategy in the. Both aristotles poetics and platos republic x address the question of the nature of poetry and its affect on its audience, taking audience as both the individual citizen and the polis as a whole. The first part discusses platos ion on mimesis and techne, as well as the role that poetry plays in the republic. Butcher in poetics by aristotle, we see the author dissect the various elements of poetry, from why we like it to what a tragedy needs to be any good. Aristotle, on the other hand, rehabilitates mimetic art in his poetics as a very natural human activity. Aristotles approach to the phenomenon of poetry is quite different from platos. A fluent new translation by our greatest living historian of philosophy of the most influential book on poetry ever written. Based on richard jankos philological reconstruction of. Acquisition and exchange are natural, but not trading for profit. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of poetics and what it means.
Analyse the points of covergence and divergence in their argument. Aristotle s poetics i ii iii iv v vi vii viii ix x xi xii xiii xiv xv xvi xvii imitation the common principle of the arts of poetry. When aristotle says, at the beginning of poetics 2, that imitation in poetry. The republic the poetics is in part aristotle s response to his teacher, plato, who argues in the republic that poetry is representation of mere appearances and is thus misleading and morally suspect. Others want to carry documents around with them on their mobile phones and read while they are on the move. Aristotles poetics is the earliest surviving work of dramatic theory and first extant philosophical. It is platos bestknown work, and has proven to be one of the worlds most influential works of philosophy and political theory, both intellectually and. Quite a few comments have been posted about poetics. Unjust legality a critique of habermass philosophy of law new critical theory. Aristotles work on aesthetics consists of the poetics, politics bk viii and rhetoric. Book ii 1 virtue, then, being of two kinds, intellectual and moral, intellectual virtue in the main owes both its birth and its growth to teaching for which reason it requires experience and time, while moral virtue comes about as a result of habit, whence also its name ethike is one that is formed by a slight variation from the word ethos.
1208 73 566 1282 652 822 426 106 732 386 1586 1133 1163 754 1608 1237 72 1369 799 438 1530 1404 1197 665 1470 290 1535 1507 934 86 78 644 10 693 1249 1054 60 77 329 1193